Home insurance claims denied percentage (17 figures)
The median published figure in the Claims Closed Without Payment is 50.90 percent across 17 figures from 5 sources' own pages (range 8 to 78 percent), read 29 September 2026.
- 18 to 19.67
- 119.67 to 31.33
- 331.33 to 43
- 543 to 54.67
- 554.67 to 66.33
- 366.33 to 78
Bands
| Bucket | Value |
|---|---|
| 8 to 20 | 1 figure |
| 20 to 31 | 1 figure |
| 31 to 43 | 3 figures |
| 43 to 55 | 5 figures |
| 55 to 66 | 5 figures |
| 66 to 78 | 3 figures |
5 of the 11 named sources read in full publish a figure; 6 publish none, read 29 September 2026.
By insurer and reason closed without payment
| Breakdown | Median | Range | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| insurer 14 large U.S. insurers (range, 2024) | 40 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Allstate Vehicle & Property | 50.9 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Allstate Insurance Company | 49.8 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer USAA | 49.5 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Mid-Century Insurance Company of Texas | 78 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Citizens Property Insurance (FL) | 61 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Fire Insurance Exchange | 55 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer MS Farm Bureau Casualty | 8 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer People's Trust | 75.4 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Kin Insurance Network | 68.3 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer American Integrity | 64.6 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Olympus Insurance | 61.9 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer State Farm Florida | 59.2 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Castle Key Indemnity Company | 47.1 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| insurer Kin Interinsurance Network | 44 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| reason closed without payment below deductible | 37 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
| reason closed without payment flood exclusion | 20 % (one figure) | one figure, no range | 1 |
Every figure, with its source
One row per published figure: the figure as the source's own page publishes it, the page, and the day it was read. A figure that is not on a page we read is not on this one.
The sentence each figure was read from (18)
- 15 Large Home Insurers Closed More Than Half of Claims in 2025 With No Payout Whatsoever | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Mid-Century Insurance Company of Texas closed 78% of homeowner claims with no payment whatsoever; Lemonade Insurance (domiciled in New York) closed 64% of homeowner claims without payment; while Spinnaker Insurance (IL) closed 61%.
- 14 Florida Insurers Closed Over Half of Homeowner Damage Claims with Zero Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
People’s Trust closed 75.4% of homeowner claims with no payment, double its rate of 2023.
- 14 Florida Insurers Closed Over Half of Homeowner Damage Claims with Zero Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Kin Insurance Network closed 68.3% with zero payment, compared to an already high 44% in the prior year.
- 14 Florida Insurers Closed Over Half of Homeowner Damage Claims with Zero Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
American Integrity closed 64.6% with zero payment, also a sharp increase from 43.9% in 2023.
- 14 Florida Insurers Closed Over Half of Homeowner Damage Claims with Zero Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Olympus Insurance closed 61.9% with no payment, far more than the 37.3% reported in the 2023.
- 15 Large Home Insurers Closed More Than Half of Claims in 2025 With No Payout Whatsoever | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Citizens Property Insurance — Florida’s state-backed insurer created to stabilize the market — also denied 61% of claims, underscoring that even public-sector solutions are not immune to the broader breakdown in claims reliability.
- 14 Florida Insurers Closed Over Half of Homeowner Damage Claims with Zero Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
And State Farm Florida, the third largest provider in the state, closed 59.2% of claims without paying homeowners a penny, versus 46.4% a year earlier.
- 15 Large Home Insurers Closed More Than Half of Claims in 2025 With No Payout Whatsoever | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Most notably, three California insurers are among the large companies that denied at least half of claims — Fire Insurance Exchange (55% denial rate), Farmers Insurance Exchange (55%), and Stillwater Insurance Co.
- 14 Large U.S. Insurers Closed Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims with No Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Allstate Vehicle & Property closed 50.9% of its 630,930 homeowner claims with no payment.
- 14 Large U.S. Insurers Closed Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims with No Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Allstate Insurance Company closed 49.8% of 952,222 claims with no payment.
- 14 Large U.S. Insurers Closed Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims with No Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
United Service Automobile Association (USAA) closed 49.5% of 547,782 claims with no payment.
- Large Property Insurers in Florida Fail to Pay Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
Among the large providers of homeowners policies in the state, Castle Key Indemnity Company denied 47.1% of the claims it closed last year, State Farm Florida Insurance Company denied 46.4%, and Castle Key Insurance Company denied 46%.
- Large Property Insurers in Florida Fail to Pay Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
In addition, three smaller providers of homeowners policies also failed to make any payment on over 40% of their claims closed in 2023: Kin Interinsurance Network (denying 44%), American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida (43.9%), and PURE Specialty Exchange (40.5%).
- Commissioner Yaworsky ... Transparency and Accountability for Hurricane Claim Denials | Florida OIR (2025-04-09), read 2026-09-29:
amounted to 41% of closed claims without payment.
- 14 Large U.S. Insurers Closed Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims with No Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
property insurers closed 40% to 51% of homeowner claims with no payment whatsoever in 2024.
- Commissioner Yaworsky ... Transparency and Accountability for Hurricane Claim Denials | Florida OIR (2025-04-09), read 2026-09-29:
amounted to 33% of closed claims without payment and flood coverage denials
- Commissioner Yaworsky ... Transparency and Accountability for Hurricane Claim Denials | Florida OIR (2025-04-09), read 2026-09-29:
amounted to 20% of closed claims without payment.
- 15 Large Home Insurers Closed More Than Half of Claims in 2025 With No Payout Whatsoever | Weiss Ratings, read 2026-09-29:
For example, MS Farm Bureau Casualty (MS) closed only 8% of claims with no payment; Homesite Insurance (WI) closed only 9%; Alfa Mutual (AL), just 13%; Property-Owners Insurance (IN), 14%; and six others, from 15% to 20% — vivid evidence that high denial rates are not inevitable, as quite a few insurers are able to operate profitably while honoring the vast majority of claims.
Read in full, publishes no figure
6 named sources were read in full on the dates shown and print no usable figure. They are counted, never filled in.
- Catastrophe Claims Data and Reporting | Florida OIR, read 2026-09-26: every candidate on the page was refused
- Wildfire Claims Tracker | California Department of Insurance, read 2026-09-29: every candidate on the page was refused
- Hurricane Ida claims report (31 Mar 2022) | Louisiana Department of Insurance, read 2026-09-29: every candidate on the page was refused
- Insured losses resulting from the February 2021 winter weather event | Texas Department of Insurance, read 2026-09-29: every candidate on the page was refused
- Hurricane Beryl Response Update | Texas Windstorm Insurance Association, read 2026-09-29: every candidate on the page was refused
- Home Insurers Ranked by Claim No-Payment Rate (2026 Study) | MoneyGeek, read 2026-09-29: every candidate on the page was refused
Methodology
Every row is a verbatim sentence read from the named source's own page through our fetch service on the date shown, hash-pinned to the stored read (the sha of the page's visible text; the raw page is mirrored to R2).
5 of the 11 named sources that could be read published a usable figure; 6 published none and are recorded as not published, never filled in; 2 could not be read (blocked, dead or unreachable) and count nowhere.
The headline figures (median, minimum, maximum, quartiles) are over ONE figure per source for each breakdown it prices, in % (a source's median where its page yielded several accepted sentences for one breakdown), so a page that gives figures for several breakdowns gives one for each and N counts 17 figures, never sentences; 82 candidate sentence(s) were refused by a reviewer with the reason recorded.
The fuller derivation this dataset is chartered to grow into (not yet what the figures above are; they are each source's own published figure as read): The closed-without-payment ratio (NAIC's Market Conduct Annual Statement ratio: claims closed without payment over all claims closed) read from every publisher of it side by side - Weiss Ratings' insurer tables built from the NAIC filings (40-51% for the 14 largest in 2024, 78% at the worst large insurer in 2025, and the Florida 46.7% the category quotes) and the regulators' own catastrophe data calls (Florida OIR for Milton, Helene, Debby, Ian and Idalia; Texas TDI; Louisiana LDI for Ida; California's wildfire claims tracker) - with the REASON split the regulators publish and Weiss does not: below the deductible (41% of Milton's closed-without-payment claims, 33% of Helene's), a flood exclusion (20% of Helene's), withdrawn or opened in error.
Computed across them: the rate by insurer, state, year and event, its change year on year, and the share of 'denials' that were not a coverage refusal at all - the figure that turns a 47% headline into what a policyholder actually faces.
82 candidate sentences on these pages were refused by a reviewer; each refusal and its reason is recorded in the review ledger.
Sources (13)
- 14 Large U.S. Insurers Closed Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims with No Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- 15 Large Home Insurers Closed More Than Half of Claims in 2025 With No Payout Whatsoever | Weiss Ratings(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- 14 Florida Insurers Closed Over Half of Homeowner Damage Claims with Zero Payment in 2024 | Weiss Ratings(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Large Property Insurers in Florida Fail to Pay Nearly Half of Homeowner Claims | Weiss Ratings(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Commissioner Yaworsky ... Transparency and Accountability for Hurricane Claim Denials | Florida OIR (2025-04-09)(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Catastrophe Claims Data and Reporting | Florida OIR(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Wildfire Claims Tracker | California Department of Insurance(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Hurricane Ida claims report (31 Mar 2022) | Louisiana Department of Insurance(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Insured losses resulting from the February 2021 winter weather event | Texas Department of Insurance(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Hurricane Beryl Response Update | Texas Windstorm Insurance Association(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Market Conduct Annual Statement Ratios 2025 | NAIC(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- Home Insurers Ranked by Claim No-Payment Rate (2026 Study) | MoneyGeek(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
- weissratings.com(the publisher's own terms; quoted for reporting and comment)
Cite or embed this figure
Cite or embed this figure
The median published figure in the Claims Closed Without Payment is 50.90 percent across 17 figures from 5 sources' own pages (range 8 to 78 percent), read 29 September 2026.
5 of the 11 named sources read in full publish a figure; 6 publish none, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer 14 large U.S. insurers (range, 2024): median 40 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Allstate Vehicle & Property: median 50.90 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Allstate Insurance Company: median 49.80 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer USAA: median 49.50 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Mid-Century Insurance Company of Texas: median 78 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Citizens Property Insurance (FL): median 61 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Fire Insurance Exchange: median 55 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer MS Farm Bureau Casualty: median 8 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer People's Trust: median 75.40 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Kin Insurance Network: median 68.30 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer American Integrity: median 64.60 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Olympus Insurance: median 61.90 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer State Farm Florida: median 59.20 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Castle Key Indemnity Company: median 47.10 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, insurer Kin Interinsurance Network: median 44 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, reason closed without payment below deductible: median 37 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Claims Closed Without Payment, reason closed without payment flood exclusion: median 20 percent across 1 source, read 29 September 2026.
Cite as: "DamageRestore HQ Claims Closed Without Payment", updated 2026-11-12, https://damagerestorehq.com/datasets/claims-closed-without-payment/.
Download the CSV (18 rows, computed 2026-11-12)
Questions this data answers
What share of homeowner claims do insurers close without paying anything - by insurer, by state and after each catastrophe - and why?
The median published figure in the Claims Closed Without Payment is 50.90 percent across 17 figures from 5 sources' own pages (range 8 to 78 percent), read 29 September 2026.
Where do the figures in the Claims Closed Without Payment come from?
Every figure is quoted from its source's own page and dated (last read 29 Sept 2026). 11 named sources were read and 5 publish a figure; the 6 that publish none are recorded as not published, never estimated.